Yes, students can be considered scholars, depending on their level of academic achievement, research, and expertise in a particular field of study.
For those who are interested in more details
Scholars are generally considered to be individuals who have achieved a high level of expertise, knowledge, and research in a particular field. Students can also be considered scholars if they have demonstrated a similar level of achievement and expertise in their studies.
According to the Merriam-Webster dictionary, a scholar is “a person who has done advanced study in a special field.” This means that anyone who has pursued higher education, engaged in in-depth research, and acquired a deep understanding of their chosen subject can be considered a scholar.
In fact, many renowned scholars throughout history were also students at some point in their lives. Albert Einstein, for example, was a student at the Swiss Federal Institute of Technology in Zurich, where he developed some of his groundbreaking theories on relativity and quantum mechanics. Another famous scholar, Marie Curie, was a student of physics and mathematics at the University of Paris, where she conducted pioneering research on radioactivity.
A quote from American author and scholar, Ralph Waldo Emerson, also highlights the potential for students to become scholars. He said, “The secret of education lies in respecting the pupil. It is not for you to choose what he shall know, what he shall do. It is chosen and foreordained, and he only holds the key to his own secret.”
It’s worth noting that scholars can come from a variety of educational backgrounds, not just traditional academic institutions. For example, individuals who have gained considerable expertise through vocational training or apprenticeships in their field can also be considered scholars.
Overall, whether students are considered scholars depends on their level of academic achievement, research, and expertise in a particular field of study. With hard work and dedication, students have the potential to become scholars and make significant contributions to their chosen field.
Here is a table summarizing the main points of the text:
| Scholars | Students |
|---|---|
| Achieve high level of expertise | Aim to achieve high level of expertise |
| Engage in in-depth research | Engage in in-depth research |
| Acquire deep understanding in their field | Acquire deep understanding in their field |
| Can come from a variety of backgrounds | Can come from a variety of educational backgrounds |
| Make significant contributions to their field | Have potential to make significant contributions to their field |
Video response to your question
The video discusses how to differentiate between a scholar and a student of knowledge. A scholar has extensive knowledge on Arabic, Quran, hadith, and fiqh and bases their opinions on the Quran and Sunnah without deviating from them. On the other hand, a student of knowledge selects from the opinions of scholars based on research. To identify a trusted scholar, one must scrutinize their conduct and look at those who have praised them. Additionally, the video advises viewers to avoid scholars who lack consistency in their teachings and beliefs and those who label others negatively, as they may be innovators and not trustworthy.
Other methods of responding to your inquiry
Learners who enroll with academic deficiencies and/or struggle academically are referred to as scholars.
Scholar as a term is considered to be more productive than a student. This little difference can still have a great impact in referring a person. A person is typically considered to be a student until he is formally enrolled with the institution whereas a scholar can forever be considered as a scholar.
Surely you will be interested in this
Knowledge Level: Students are in the process of acquiring foundational knowledge and skills, while scholars have already attained a high level of expertise in their field.